Experts told RenewEconomy on 18 November 2026 that Australia’s electricity networks are gradually pushing into competitive markets, and that the ring-fencing rules designed to stop this are being weakened. The trigger is a draft rule from the Australian Energy Market Commission (AEMC), released in September 2026, supporting a federal $40 million EV charging program in which network businesses have a role. Critics say the precedent could reduce competition and push costs onto power bills.
This matters beyond EV charging. The same ring-fencing rules also govern whether a network can own community batteries or run rooftop solar programs, which are markets that private installers and energy companies compete in today.
Short answer: Ring-fencing keeps monopoly poles-and-wires businesses out of competitive markets so customers get choice and fair prices. Critics argue exceptions are multiplying. The AEMC says its draft rule is limited to one federal program, and no final decision has been made. For businesses, the practical advice is to understand where regulated network costs end and competitive services begin, and to keep your energy assets under your own control.
Disclosure: Smart Energy Answers operates in the competitive solar and battery market, so we have an interest in this topic. We have tried to set out the arguments on both sides.
What is ring-fencing, and why does it exist?
Electricity distribution networks are regulated monopolies. You cannot choose a different set of poles and wires. Ring-fencing is the set of rules that stops those monopolies from using that position to compete unfairly in markets where you do have a choice.
The Australian Energy Regulator (AER) runs the Electricity Distribution Ring-fencing Guideline. It requires networks to separate the legal, accounting and functional sides of regulated services from other services. The guideline is legally binding, and version 4 has applied to distribution businesses since 27 February 2025.
The rules can be waived. The AER can grant a ring-fencing waiver for a specific project, and has done so for trials and for some battery programs. Critics say waivers are being used too often. Supporters say they let useful ideas be tested under conditions.
What is the new dispute about?
The latest flashpoint is kerbside EV charging. Here is how the pieces fit together, based on RenewEconomy’s reporting and the AEMC’s own releases:
- The Commonwealth’s Accelerating EV Charging Program is a $40 million program aimed at regional charging blackspots and high-density areas. It is scheduled to conclude on 30 June 2029.
- The AEMC released a draft rule on 24 September 2026 to enable the rollout of around 14,000 chargers under that program.
- AEMC Chair Anna Collyer said the draft rule applies only to this program and does not give networks a broader role in EV charging.
- Submissions closed on 5 November 2026, with a final determination due by the end of 2026.
- Separately, the AEMC is running a wider review of network regulation. It includes a request from Energy Networks Australia (ENA) to let networks install, own and maintain kerbside chargers as a regulated service, and a request from Nexa Advisory to tighten ring-fencing. A draft determination on those is planned by 20 May 2027.
Critics are not convinced the draft rule will stay narrow. Thirteen organisations, including AGL, EnergyAustralia, ENGIE and Tesla, signed an open letter in October challenging it.
At a glance: the key facts
|
Topic
|
What the evidence says
|
|
The warning
|
Experts say network involvement in consumer energy is eroding competition and could raise bills (RenewEconomy, 18 Nov 2026)
|
|
The rule in question
|
AEMC draft rule, 24 Sept 2026, supporting the federal $40 million Accelerating EV Charging Program
|
|
Scope per the AEMC
|
Applies only to that program (ends 30 June 2029); no broader network role in EV charging
|
|
Scale
|
Around 14,000 chargers in regional and high-density areas
|
|
Cost to bills (AEMC estimate)
|
About $1 per household bill per network area for installation; ongoing operating costs not estimated, per RenewEconomy
|
|
Critics’ figure
|
The Justice and Equity Centre says about 70% of costs fall on consumer bills
|
|
Next step
|
Final determination due by end of 2026; wider network review draft due by 20 May 2027
|
|
Who is affected
|
All electricity customers, plus businesses selling or installing EV chargers, batteries and solar
|
What do critics say?
The critics quoted by RenewEconomy make several connected arguments:
- Cross-subsidy. The Justice and Equity Centre says the costs of the chargers would largely be recovered from general electricity customers, including those who do not own an EV.
- Guaranteed returns. Evie Networks argues that private operators invest at their own risk, while networks can deploy where it suits them because customers underwrite their returns.
- Break-even gap. The article reports networks would need roughly 1.5 to 3.8 more EVs on the road per charger to break even, while private operators can break even straight away.
- Access barriers. Pole access charges reportedly range from nothing to $300,000 per pole, and connection timeframes can stretch for months.
- Weak evidence. Nexa Advisory’s Stephanie Bashir, who helped write the original ring-fencing rules, argues the AEMC is acting without evidence. The article says the AEMC itself acknowledged there is no evidence kerbside chargers lift EV uptake.
What do networks and the regulator say?
Networks argue they already own the poles and hold location data, so they are the logical owners of pole-mounted chargers. ENA says its request is not about networks selling electricity to EV drivers: networks would supply the infrastructure while competitive providers offer the charging services.
The AEMC says it weighed emissions benefits against costs to consumers, competition among charging providers and access for people without off-street parking. It describes the program as targeted and time-limited.
Not everyone is on one side. The Clean Energy Council has supported a greater enabling role for networks in connections, planning and data, while stressing the need for competitive fairness.
Is this only about EV chargers?
No. Batteries and rooftop solar have raised the same question.
- In 2023 the AER granted a class waiver allowing networks limited rights to own and operate community batteries funded under the federal Community Batteries program, a decision Nexa Advisory opposed.
- In late 2025 the AER granted Ausgrid a five-year trial waiver for its Community Power Network in two NSW locations (Charmhaven and Mascot/Botany). Ausgrid would offer incentives for more rooftop solar and use community-scale batteries to store and redistribute energy.
- Energex applied in November 2025 for a waiver covering six battery units.
- In June 2026 the AER opened a joint review of its ring-fencing and shared asset guidelines, and a range of industry submissions are on its website.
Networks say this kind of work can reduce the need for grid spending. Critics say a regulated business should not own contestable assets that private companies could provide.
What could this mean for your bills?
The direct figures so far are small. The AEMC’s estimate for installation costs is about $1 a year on a household bill per network area, according to RenewEconomy. The concern is more about precedent and unknown ongoing costs:
- Regulated network costs are shared across all customers on that network, whether or not they use the service.
- If networks own more assets, a larger share of spending moves into regulated charges, where customers have no choice about paying.
- If private competitors are crowded out, there is less price pressure on contestable services.
That is why the question to ask is not only “how much?” but “who carries the risk if usage falls short?”
Who should pay attention?
Businesses planning EV chargers for staff, customers or fleets
The rules will shape who can install chargers on public land near your site and who pays for the connection.
Businesses with solar and batteries
Network-led programs could change how local battery capacity, export limits and incentives are offered in your area.
Businesses in apartment buildings, shopping centres and strata
Kerbside and shared-asset models are aimed at these locations.
Energy-intensive sites
Any growth in regulated network costs flows into network tariffs, which you pay on top of energy costs.
Installers, charge point operators and energy retailers
These are the competitive providers whose markets are affected.
How can you protect your position?
- Own and control your assets. Solar and batteries on your own site, under your own contract, keep control of how your energy is used and stored.
- Ask who the service provider is. When offered a battery, charger or solar program, check whether it is a competitive provider or a network program and what the terms are.
- Read the data and control terms. Ask who can see your usage data and who can control your devices, and for how long.
- Compare offers. Where a competitive market exists, quotes from several providers keep prices honest.
- Watch your network tariff. Regulated network charges are set in multi-year determinations, so changes can lag.
Is your business ready? A quick checklist
- Do you know which network (distributor) serves each of your sites?
- Do you know your network tariff and how it is structured?
- Are you planning EV charging, solar or batteries in the next 12 to 24 months?
- Have you been offered a network-run or council-linked program, and read the terms?
- Do you know who owns the meter and any control equipment at your site?
- Do you have a contract that lets you move or add providers later?
If you answered no to several of these, a short review before you commit to any program is worthwhile.
Five steps to take now
1. Review your electricity setup
Identify your network, tariff, meter and any existing programs or controls.
2. Map your plans
List any planned solar, batteries or EV chargers and the sites involved.
3. Compare competitive options
Get quotes from independent providers before accepting a network-led offer.
4. Check the fine print
Look at ownership, data access, device control, exit rights and fees.
5. Track the decisions
The AEMC’s final determination on the EV program is due by the end of 2026, and the wider network review follows in 2027. Consider making a submission through an industry body if the outcome affects your business.
Is this the right time to act?
The EV rule is a draft, the wider review is still ahead, and the AEMC says its draft does not create a broader role for networks. Nothing has changed for your bill today.
But decisions about who can own and operate energy assets in your neighbourhood are being shaped now. If you are planning solar, batteries or chargers, understanding the landscape before you sign is cheaper than unwinding a contract afterwards.
Key takeaways
- Ring-fencing separates monopoly network services from competitive ones. It is a legally binding AER guideline, but waivers are possible.
- The AEMC’s September 2026 draft rule is limited to the $40 million federal EV charging program, according to the AEMC.
- Critics say it sets a precedent that could raise costs for all customers and weaken competition. Networks and the AEMC dispute that framing.
- The same debate covers community batteries and rooftop solar programs, such as Ausgrid’s Community Power Network trial.
- Final decisions are still to come, so businesses should stay informed and keep control of their own energy assets.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What is ring-fencing in the Australian electricity market?
A: Ring-fencing is a set of AER rules that separate regulated monopoly network services from competitive services. It aims to stop networks using their monopoly position to gain an unfair advantage.
Q: What is the AEMC’s draft rule on EV charging?
A: Released on 24 September 2026, it supports the federal $40 million Accelerating EV Charging Program, which targets around 14,000 chargers. The AEMC says it applies only to that program, which ends on 30 June 2029.
Q: Will this raise my electricity bill?
A: The AEMC’s installation cost estimate is about $1 per household bill per network area, per RenewEconomy. Critics worry about ongoing costs and precedent, and the final rule is not yet decided.
Q: Can electricity networks own batteries or solar?
A: Not normally, because of ring-fencing. The AER has granted waivers for specific programs, including community batteries and Ausgrid’s five-year Community Power Network trial.
Q: Why do critics say network involvement harms competition?
A: They argue networks have guaranteed regulated returns, so they carry less risk than private companies and can crowd them out. They also point to networks’ control of poles, connections and customer data.
Q: What do networks say?
A: Networks say they own the infrastructure and have the location data, and that they would provide infrastructure while competitive providers deliver services. They also argue community batteries can reduce grid costs.
Q: Does this affect businesses with solar and batteries?
A: Not directly today. It could affect local battery programs, incentives and how network programs interact with your site, so it is worth tracking.
Q: When will decisions be made?
A: The AEMC’s final determination on the EV program is due by the end of 2026. A draft determination on the wider network review is planned by 20 May 2027.
What could this look like for your business?
Whether you are adding solar, a battery or EV chargers, the right structure depends on your site, your network and your contract.
Ready to See What You Could Save?
Book a Consultation.
Get In Touch
Sources